Sunday, March 23, 2025

Interesting question. Do we have an answer?

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5179224

Artificial Intelligence and the Discrimination Injury

For a decade, scholars have debated whether discrimination involving artificial intelligence (AI) can be captured by existing discrimination laws. This article argues that the challenge that artificial intelligence poses for discrimination law stems not from the specifics of any statute, but from the very conceptual framework of discrimination law. Discrimination today is a species of tort, concerned with rectifying individual injuries, rather than a law aimed at broadly improving social or economic equality. As a result, the doctrine centers blameworthiness and individualized notions of injury. But it is also a strange sort of tort that does not clearly define its injury. Defining the discrimination harm is difficult and contested. As a result, the doctrine skips over the injury question and treats a discrimination claim as a process question about whether a defendant acted properly in a single decisionmaking event. This tort-with-unclear-injury formulation effectively merges the questions of injury and liability: If a defendant did not act improperly, then no liability attaches because a discrimination event did not occur. Injury is tied to the single decision event and there is no room for recognizing discrimination injury without liability.

This formulation directly affects regulation of AI discrimination for two reasons: First, AI decisionmaking is distributed; it is a combination of software development, its configuration, and its application, all of which are completed at different times and usually by different parties. This means that the mental model of a single decision and decisionmaker breaks down in this context. Second, the process-based injury is fundamentally at odds with the existence of “discriminatory” technology as a concept. While we can easily conceive of discriminatory AI as a colloquial matter, if there is legally no discrimination event until the technology is used in an improper way, then the technology cannot be considered discriminatory until it is improperly used.

The analysis leads to two ultimate conclusions. First, while the applicability of disparate impact law to AI is unknown, as no court has addressed the question head-on, liability will depend in large part on the degree to which a court is willing to hold a decisionmaker (e.g. and employer, lender, or landlord) liable for using a discriminatory technology without adequate attention to the effects, for a failure to either comparison shop or fix the AI. Given the shape of the doctrine, the fact that the typical decisionmaker is not tech savvy, and that they likely purchased the technology on the promise of it being non- discriminatory, whether a court would find such liability is an open question. Second, discrimination law cannot be used to create incentives or penalties for the people best able to address the problem of discriminatory AI—the developers themselves. The Article therefore argues for supplementing discrimination law with the application of a combination of consumer protection, product safety, and products liability—all legal doctrines meant to address the distribution of harmful products on the open market, and all better suited to directly addressing the products that create discriminatory harms.





Can AI help?

https://taapublications.com/tijsrat/article/view/453

THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON LEGAL SYSTEMS

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming sectors of the world, and the legal sector is no different. The emerging use of AI technologies into the judiciary has gigantic potential and issues. However, AI holds the potential to enhance the efficacy of legal processes by automating routine tasks like document searching, legal analysis, and contract analysis,reducing the cost of legal services, and making legal services more accessible. Artificial intelligence technologies such as predictive analytics also possess the ability to facilitate better decision-making by having the ability to distinguish between case law trends and predict outcomes. However, the universal application of AI also presents firm ethical, legal, and privacy concerns. Of these is the possibility of algorithmic bias, which can lead to biased or discriminatory judicial decisions. Another problem is a lack of transparency in AI decision-making, and therefore it can be difficult to explain how algorithms make decisions. Also, AI poses problems for traditional legal systems, as they were designed to take into account passive systems, not active ones. This paper discusses the advantages as well as challenges of AI legal systems, having a detailed look at their implications for lawyers, clients, and lawmakers. By this analysis, the paper emphasizes the need for a balanced regulatory environment for ensuring ethical use of AI while protecting individuals' rights and upholding justice in the legal system.





Perspective.

https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/article/view/18975

Authoritarian Surveillance: An Introduction

Authoritarian surveillance is no longer an exceptional or rare practice. In many parts of the world, we are witnessing an increase of pervasive government monitoring, of curtailing privacy protections, of stringent control of information flows, and of intimidation towards self-censorship. These hallmarks of authoritarian surveillance are not confined to authoritarian or undemocratic regimes. In a political landscape that favours strongarm authoritarian leaders, the boundaries between authoritarian and democratic regimes, the liberal and the illiberal ones, are blurrier than ever. The increasing availability of advanced technologies for analyzing (big) data, particularly when integrated with artificial intelligence (AI), has heightened the temptation for governments to adopt authoritarian surveillance tools and practices—and has amplified the potential dangers involved.

This Dialogue section introduces the multiple dimensions of contemporary authoritarian surveillance, going beyond a dichotomy between “democratic” and “authoritarian” regimes to identify and map authoritarian surveillance in diverse geographical and political contexts. We focus on surveillance beyond the exceptional and beyond the rule of law to examine an increasingly mundane but dangerous practice undermining the limited democratic spaces that remain in our world. The seven articles in this special Dialogue section explore different angles of authoritarian surveillance— the technologies that facilitate it, the laws that govern it, and the legacies that precede it or linger thereafter—and the social and political consequences that emerge as a result. Together, this collection revisits existing literature on authoritarian surveillance, calls for a renewed scholarly focus on its consequences, and proposes new directions for future research.

Vol. 23 No. 1 (2025): Open Issue





Perspective.

https://sites.duke.edu/lawfire/2025/03/22/podcast-lt-gen-jack-shanahan-usaf-ret-on-the-military-uses-of-artificial-intelligence/

Podcast: Lt Gen Jack Shanahan, USAF (Ret.) on “The Military Uses of Artificial Intelligence”

Want to get caught up on the latest about artificial intelligence (AI) in the armed forces?  Then today’s video of Prof Gary Corn’s, Fireside Chat with Lt Gen John N.T. “Jack” Shanahan, USAF (Ret.), the former Director of the Department of Defense’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center, on “The Military Uses of Artificial Intelligence” is for you.



Saturday, March 22, 2025

Luddites?

https://www.fastcompany.com/91302120/employees-are-actively-sabotaging-ai-efforts-heres-why

31% of employees are actively ‘sabotaging’ AI efforts. Here’s why

According to a new study by generative AI platform Writer, 31% of employees—including 41% of Gen Z workers—admit to “sabotaging” their company’s AI strategy by refusing to adopt AI tools and applications. As a result, roughly two-third of executives say Generative AI adoption has led to tension and division within their organization, with 42% suggesting it’s “tearing their company apart.”





Did META steal your work?

https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2025/03/my-writings-are-in-the-libgen-ai-training-corpus.html

My Writings Are in the LibGen AI Training Corpus

The Atlantic has a search tool that allows you to search for specific works in the “LibGen” database of copyrighted works that Meta used to train its AI models. (The rest of the article is behind a paywall, but not the search tool.)

It’s impossible to know exactly which parts of LibGen Meta used to train its AI, and which parts it might have decided to exclude; this snapshot was taken in January 2025, after Meta is known to have accessed the database, so some titles here would not have been available to download.

Still…interesting.

Searching my name yields 199 results: all of my books in different versions, plus a bunch of shorter items.



Friday, March 21, 2025

Links to all the papers.

https://fpf.org/blog/global/fpf-privacy-papers-for-policymakers-a-celebration-of-impactful-privacy-research-and-scholarship/

FPF Privacy Papers for Policymakers: A Celebration of Impactful Privacy Research and Scholarship

The Future of Privacy Forum (FPF) hosted its 15th Privacy Papers for Policymakers (PPPM) event at its Washington, D.C., headquarters on March 12, 2025. This prestigious event recognized six outstanding research papers that offer valuable insights for policymakers navigating the ever-evolving landscape of privacy and technology. The evening featured engaging discussions and a shared commitment to advancing informed policymaking in digital privacy.





To be expected…

https://www.forbes.com/sites/hessiejones/2025/03/20/risk-or-revolution-will-ai-replace-lawyers/

Risk Or Revolution: Will AI Replace Lawyers?

As artificial intelligence reshapes many industries, the legal field faces its own crossroads. Over the past few years, a growing number of legal professionals have embraced AI tools to boost efficiency and reduce costs. According to recent figures, nearly 73% of legal experts now plan to incorporate AI into their daily operations.  65% of law firms agree that "effective use of generative AI will separate the successful and unsuccessful law firms in the next five years."

Investors have shown strong support for AI-powered legal startups, with funding reaching new record highs in 2024 with total capital investment of $477 million. The appeal for VCs is the potential that 44% of legal work could potentially be automated by emerging AI tools. Startups like Harvey, raised a $100 million Series C round at a $1.5 billion valuation.

We explore the current state of legal automation with Ben Su, Co-founder and Head of Growth of Capita, the world’s first AI lawyer, and discuss how this shift towards AI could reshape the delivery of legal services.



Thursday, March 20, 2025

Don’t understand or don’t care – same result.

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2025/03/doge-to-fired-cisa-staff-email-us-your-personal-data/

DOGE to Fired CISA Staff: Email Us Your Personal Data

A message posted on Monday to the homepage of the U.S. Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) is the latest exhibit in the Trump administration’s continued disregard for basic cybersecurity protections. The message instructed recently-fired CISA employees to get in touch so they can be rehired and then immediately placed on leave, asking employees to send their Social Security number or date of birth in a password-protected email attachment — presumably with the password needed to view the file included in the body of the email.



(Ditto)

https://www.bespacific.com/emails-reveal-top-irs-lawyer-warned-trump-firings-were-a-fraud-on-the-courts/

Emails Reveal Top IRS Lawyer Warned Trump Firings Were a “Fraud” on the Courts

ProPublica: “On Feb. 20, nearly 7,000 probationary employees at the Internal Revenue Service began receiving an unsigned letter telling them that they had been fired for poor performance. Trump administration lawyers insist that the IRS and other federal agencies have acted within their authority when they ordered waves of mass terminations since Trump took office. But according to previously unreported emails obtained by ProPublica, a top lawyer at the IRS warned administration officials that the performance-related language in his agency’s termination letter was “a false statement” that amounted to “fraud” if the agency kept the language in the letter. The emails reveal that in the hours before the IRS sent out its Feb. 20 termination letter, a fierce dispute played out at the agency’s highest levels. Joseph Rillotta, a senior IRS lawyer, wrote that “no one” at the IRS had taken into account the performance of the probationary workers set to be fired. Rillotta urged that the language be struck from the draft termination letter. If the falsehood wasn’t removed, Rillotta said he would file a report with the inspector general for the IRS.”





Not sure I agree (or maybe I just don’t understand) – if I don’t have a duty to protect, can I leave your data unprotected?

https://pogowasright.org/the-differences-between-non-disclosure-exfiltration-and-notice-a-courts-view/

The differences between non-disclosure, exfiltration and notice – a court’s view

David Kessler and Sue Ross write:

Although there is scant case law on the question, it is generally accepted that it is not a violation of one’s duty not to disclose information if it is stolen from you.  Put another way, disclosure is an affirmative act, and, absent an affirmative duty to protect information from unauthorized access, theft of information is not a violation of a duty not to disclose.
This question, however, was at the heart of the decision in  Gerber v. Twitter, Inc., case no. 4:23-cv-00186-KAW (N.D. Cal. Dec. 18, 2024) (2024 WL 5173313).  Judge Kandis Westmore ruled that a social media platform’s duty not to disclose personal information is not the same as the duty to protect that information against theft.  Further, the duty not to disclose does mean the social media platform has a duty to notify individuals if  the social media platform is breached.  As a result, the court granted in part and denied in part the defendant’s motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ complaint.  (Id.)

Read more at Data Protection Report.





Perspective. The more tools we provide to make life easier the less anyone wants to keep doing things the “old way.”

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-03-19/michael-bloomberg-kids-are-spending-too-much-class-time-on-laptops

Kids Are Spending Too Much Class Time on Laptops

Over the past two decades, school districts have spent billions of taxpayer dollars equipping classrooms with laptops and other devices in hopes of preparing kids for a digital future. The result? Students have fallen further behind on the skills they most need to succeed in careers: the three R’s plus a fourth — relationships.

… Just 28% of eighth graders are proficient in math and 30% in reading. For 12th graders, the numbers are similarly dismal (24% in math and 37% in reading, according to the most recently available scores). And US students have also fallen further behind their peers in other countries.





Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Not all consequences are intentional.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2025-03-19/trump-cbp-one-app-shutdown-is-a-gift-to-mexico-cartel-smugglers

Trump’s App Shutdown Is a Gift to Mexico’s Cartels

There were few fond obituaries in the American press last week when the Trump administration announced that it was shutting down CBP One, the app immigrants had once been able to use to schedule asylum appointments with US Customs and Border Protection. Even before the administration largely disabled the app in January, immigrant-rights advocates had complained for years that the software was glitchy and difficult to use. They also said it helped officials illegally limit the flow of asylum seekers into the country, while MAGA types tarred it for supposedly making entry too easy.

South of the border, however, the app will be missed. Some immigrants and those who work with them say it provided a rare alternative to Mexican drug cartels’ exploitative, often-violent system of human smuggling and trafficking. For “many, many” asylum seekers with reasonable claims, the app proved to be an essential lifeline and a peaceful substitute for cartel muscle, says Pastor Guillermo Navarrete, who runs the Tijuana side of the Border Church, a weekly Methodist service held on both sides of the rust-colored border wall. As its capabilities expanded over the past couple of years, “it was a surprise from the American government,” Navarrete says, “because it was useful.”





Perspective.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/389913336_ChatGPT_and_academic_work_new_psychological_phenomena

ChatGPT and academic work: new psychological phenomena

This study describes the impact of ChatGPT use on the nature of work from the perspective of academics and educators. We elucidate six phenomena: (1) the cognitive workload associated with conducting Turing tests to determine if ChatGPT has been involved in work productions; (2) the ethical void and alienation that result from recondite ChatGPT use; (3) insights into the motives of individuals who fail to disclose their ChatGPT use, while, at the same time, the recipient does not reveal their awareness of that use; (4) the sense of ennui as the meanings of texts dissipate and no longer reveal the sender’s state of understanding; (5) a redefinition of utility, wherein certain texts show redundancy with patterns already embedded in the base model, while physical measurements and personal observations are considered as unique and novel; (6) a power dynamic between sender and recipient, inadvertently leaving non-participants as disadvantaged third parties. This paper makes clear that the introduction of AI tools into society has far-reaching effects, initially most prominent in text-related fields, such as academia. Whether these implementations represent beneficial innovations for human prosperity, or a rather different line of social evolution, represents the pith of our present discussion.





Leading indicator…

https://www.reuters.com/world/us-suspends-some-efforts-counter-russian-sabotage-trump-moves-closer-putin-2025-03-19/

Exclusive: US suspends some efforts to counter Russian sabotage as Trump moves closer to Putin

Several U.S. national security agencies have halted work on a coordinated effort to counter Russian sabotage, disinformation and cyberattacks, easing pressure on Moscow as the Trump Administration pushes Russia to end its war in Ukraine.



Trailing datum…

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/mar/18/russia-criminal-networks-drive-increase-sabotage-europol

Russia using criminal networks to drive increase in sabotage acts, says Europol

Russia and other state actors are driving an increase in politically motivated cyber-attacks and sabotage of infrastructure and public institutions in the EU, the bloc’s police enforcement agency has found.

Europol’s 80-page serious and organised crime threat assessment for 2025 also describes in detail how “hybrid threat” actors have established a “shadow alliance” with organised criminal gangs in Europe to try to destabilise the functioning of the EU and its member states.





Could be useful.

https://www.bespacific.com/50-free-datasets-in-50-minutes/

50 Free Datasets in 50 Minutes

50 Free Datasets in 50 Minutes. National Institute for Computer-Assisted Reporting. Minneapolis, Minnesota, March 6, 2025: “Below are federal government datasets with individual-level structured data that can be downloaded for free as Excel or CSV files and localized to any city, county or state in the United States. Unless noted, all the data is updated and can be used to analyze trends, as well as comparisons for your community to the rest of your state, or nation. Some datasets include addresses or longitude/latitude to enable mapping. Most of the datasets are available directly from the government agency, but we have provided other datasets that reputable data journalists or organizations have acquired, often through FOIA, cleaned up and provided to you for free (e.g., Data Liberation Project, started by Jeremy Singer-Vine and now coordinated by MuckRock and Big Local News). All of these datasets empower you to localize federal-level data to your community. Links can be dynamic and ever changing, so if one ends up being broken, Google to find its new location. Also, we provide the actual URL so you can put it in the Internet Archive to see what the website contained in the past. Some datasets can be pretty complicated, but most sites provide code sheets and data dictionaries to explain the content. Also, in many cases, tipsheets from previous IRE/NICAR conferences available at the IRE Resource Center go into depth in how to interpret the data, and the pros, cons, limitations and pitfalls of particular datasets…

Search websites of data gatherers who have already pulled together federal datasets and posted them online, then acquire the data yourself. They include the Data Liberation Project, Data is Plural, the Accountability Project, MuckRock, Kaggle, Google Dataset Search,  GovernmentAttic.org,  ProPublica (check their archived data store list, which isn’t updated, but provides good ideas), and Big Local News…”



Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Perspective. A nation of shoppers…

https://searchengineland.com/generative-ai-surging-online-shopping-report-453312

Generative AI use surging among consumers for online shopping: Report

Traffic from generative AI surged to U.S. retail sites over the holiday season and that trend has continued into 2025, according to new Adobe data.

Between Nov. 1 and Dec. 31, traffic from generative AI sources increased by 1,300% compared to the year prior (up 1,950% YoY on Cyber Monday).

This trend continued beyond the holiday season, Adobe found. In February, traffic from generative AI sources increased by 1,200% compared to July 2024.

The percentages are high because generative AI tools are so new. ChatGPT debuted its research preview on Nov. 30. 2022. Generative AI traffic remains modest compared to other channels, such as paid search or email, but the growth is notable. It’s doubled every two months since September 2024.





Never ask questions if you won’t like the answers?

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/17/trump-russia-ukraine

Trump administration pulls US out of body investigating Ukraine invasion

The Trump administration is withdrawing from an international body formed to investigate responsibility for the invasion of Ukraine in the latest sign that the White House is adopting a posture favouring Vladimir Putin.

The Department of Justice said it was pulling out of the International Centre for the Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression against Ukraine (ICPA) two years after the Biden administration joined it with a commitment to hold Putin, Russia’s president, to account for the 2022 invasion and subsequent crimes committed by Russian forces.



Sunday, March 16, 2025

Can harm be backtracked to a probable cause?

https://databreaches.net/2025/03/16/courts-are-still-willing-to-dismiss-data-breach-lawsuits-for-lack-of-standing/

Courts Are Still Willing To Dismiss Data Breach Lawsuits for Lack of Standing

Raika Casey and Alexis Opper of BakerHostetler write:

In data breach litigation, courts generally find plaintiffs have standing such that their complaints may proceed past the pleading stage when it is alleged that sensitive information was impacted and there is an allegation of dark web exposure, misuse or fraud. However, a few courts have recently dismissed proposed data breach class actions despite these factors being alleged.
For example, in Maser v. CommonSpirit Health, a Colorado district court dismissed a proposed data breach class action, finding that the plaintiff failed to allege an injury-in-fact fairly traceable to the data breach despite allegations that she experienced bank fraud and a drop in her credit score. No. 1:23-cv-01073-RM-SBP (D. Colo. Dec. 4, 2024). Because the plaintiff’s bank information was not compromised in the breach and “none of the stolen data fields in and of themselves can enable fraud,” the court held that the alleged harms were not fairly traceable to the breach and, therefore, her other injury allegations were insufficient to support standing.

Read more at Data Counsel.





Read worthy?

https://pogowasright.org/new-book-on-privacy-and-technology/

New Book: ON PRIVACY AND TECHNOLOGY

Law professor and privacy law scholar Dan Solove recently announced the publication of his new book, On Privacy and Technology.

Can privacy law keep up with new digital technologies such as AI?
The book is a short accessible overview of my thinking about privacy for the past 25 years. I tried my best to make it short and engaging – it’s about 130 pages.





And another word to define?

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5170170

Humanist Copyright

This exploration of the role of authorship in copyright law proceeds in three parts: historical, doctrinal, and predictive. First, I will review the development of authorfocused property rights in the pre-copyright regimes of printing privileges and in early Anglo-American copyright law through the 1909 U.S. Copyright Act. Second, I will analyze the extent to which the present U.S. copyright law does (and does not) honor human authorship. Finally, I will consider the potential responses of copyright law to the claims of proprietary rights in AI-generated outputs. I will explain why the humanist orientation of US copyright law validates the position of the Copyright Office and the courts that the output of an AI system will not be a "work of authorship" unless human participation has determinatively caused the creation of the output.





How are we doing?

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5172957

Legitimizing Ai: Ethical Ai in Corporate Ethics Statements

This study examines organizations’ ethics statements on artificial intelligence (AI). Drawing on the legitimacy framework, this study investigates how these statements serve as mechanisms to align organizational AI practices with stakeholder expectations, establish ethical benchmarks, and deploy strategic legitimation cues. Among the Fortune Global 500 and Forbes AI 50 companies, 101 (18.36%) have published corporate AI ethics statements. A quantitative content analysis of these statements reveals that intelligibility, safety, and justice are widely recognized as key ethical AI standards. The statements frequently address customers and employees as primary stakeholders, emphasizing intelligibility and privacy for customers and safety, intelligibility, and accountability for employees. Substantive cues are more prevalent than symbolic cues in legitimizing these ethical AI standards. The findings offer valuable insights for corporate management and communication professionals and a foundational guideline for developing and evaluating corporate AI ethics statements.



Saturday, March 15, 2025

This could have been avoided if they just RTFM! (Read the friendly manual)

https://www.cleveland.com/news/2025/01/cleveland-police-used-ai-to-justify-a-search-warrant-it-has-derailed-a-murder-case.html?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email

Cleveland police used AI to justify a search warrant. It has derailed a murder case

A jury may never see the gun that authorities say was used to kill Blake Story last year.

That’s because Cleveland police used a facial recognition program – one that explicitly says its results are not admissible in court – to obtain a search warrant, according to court documents.

The search turned up what police say is the murder weapon in the suspect’s home. But a Cuyahoga County judge tossed that evidence after siding with defense attorneys who argued that the search warrant affidavit was misleading and relied on inadmissible evidence.



(Related)

https://www.vpm.org/news/2025-03-14/cliff-hayes-general-assembly-ai-oversight-court-decisions-facial-recognition

Virginia legislation calls for human oversight of AI use in court decisions

Virginia lawmakers want to regulate the use of artificial intelligence-based tools in the criminal justice system.

During this year’s General Assembly session, Del. Cliff Hayes Jr. (D–Chesapeake) introduced a bill  that would reinforce human oversight in the criminal justice system while allowing AI to play a supporting role.

Hayes’ bill would prohibit AI-generated recommendations from being used as the sole basis for key decisions related to pre-trial detention or release, prosecution, adjudication, sentencing, probation, parole, correctional supervision, or rehabilitation. It would also make any use of AI in those decisions subject to legal challenge or objection.



Friday, March 14, 2025

Might be interesting…

https://www.bespacific.com/vals-legal-ai-report/

Vals Legal AI Report

Vals Legal AI Report  [free-registration required] “This first-of-its-kind study evaluates how four legal AI tools perform across seven legal tasks, benchmarking their results against those produced by a lawyer control group (the Lawyer Baseline). The seven tasks evaluated in this study were Data Extraction, Document Q&A, Document Summarization, Redlining, Transcript Analysis, Chronology Generation, and EDGAR Research, representing a range of functions commonly performed by legal professionals. The evaluated tools were CoCounsel (from Thomson Reuters), Vincent AI (from vLex), Harvey Assistant (from Harvey), and Oliver (from Vecflow). Lexis+AI (from LexisNexis) was initially evaluated but withdrew from the sections studied in this report. The percentages below represent each tool’s accuracy or performance scores based on predefined evaluation criteria for each legal task. Higher percentages indicate stronger performance relative to other AI tools and the Lawyer Baseline. Some key takeaways include:

    • Harvey opted into six out of seven tasks. They received the top scores of the participating AI tools on five tasks and placed second on one task. In four tasks, they outperformed the Lawyer Baseline.

    • CoCounsel is the only other vendor whose AI tool received a top score. It consistently ranked among the top-performing tools for the four evaluated tasks, with scores ranging from 73.2% to 89.6%.

    • The Lawyer Baseline outperformed the AI tools on two tasks and matched the best-performing tool on one task. In the four remaining tasks, at least one AI tool surpassed the Lawyer Baseline.

Beyond these headline findings, a more detailed analysis of each tool’s performance reveals additional insights into their relative strengths, limitations, and areas for improvement.”





Perspective.

https://www.scrippsnews.com/science-and-tech/artificial-intelligence/half-of-americans-regularly-use-artificial-intelligence-tech-like-chatgpt-survey-says

Half of Americans regularly use artificial intelligence tech like ChatGPT, survey says

Half of Americans are now using artificial intelligence models like ChatGPT and Gemini, according to a new survey from researchers at Elon University.

… "Younger, well-educated, relatively wealthy, and employed adults are somewhat more likely than others to be using LLMs now. Yet, it is also the case that half of those living in households earning less than $50,000 (53%) use the tools," the researchers said.

The technology is more popular among Hispanic adults (66%) and Black adults (57%) than White adults (47%), the survey found. It's also slightly more popular among women than men.

How often the LLMs are used varies: 34% said they use them at least once a day, 18% said they use them several times a week and 10% said they use the tools “almost constantly.”



Thursday, March 13, 2025

Interesting list.

https://www.bespacific.com/the-200-sites-an-ice-surveillance-contractor-is-monitoring/

404 Media has obtained a list of 200+ sites monitored by a contractor for ICE

404 Media [unpaywalled] – “A contractor for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and many other U.S. government agencies has developed a tool that lets analysts more easily pull a target individual’s publicly available data from a wide array of sites, social networks, apps, and services across the web at once, including Amazon, Apple Music, BabyCenter, Bluesky, Facebook, Github, GoFundMe, OnlyFans, Instagra, according to a leaked list of the sites obtained by 404 Media. In all the list names more than 200 sites that the contractor, called ShadowDragon, pulls data from and makes available to its government clients, allowing them to map out a person’s activity, movements, and relationships.”

404 Media has uploaded the list here.





I did not know that. Perhaps I’ll take another look. What other industries use it this way?

https://www.bespacific.com/the-legal-professions-shift-to-linkedin-what-you-need-to-know/

The Legal Profession’s Shift to LinkedIn: What You Need to Know

Nicole Black – LinkedIn – “A decade ago, LinkedIn was little more than a digital resume. Today, it’s the primary networking platform for legal professionals. It’s come a long way since the book I co-authored about social media for lawyers was published by the American Bar Association in 2010. Back then, LinkedIn barely merited a mention. Interaction on the platform was minimal, and its primary benefit was assisting with job searches. At the time, Twitter and Facebook were the top social networks for legal professionals, and Instagram was in its infancy. If you’d suggested to me that one day LinkedIn would be my primary social media outlet, I’d have called you crazy… There are many recent feature updates that make the platform more engaging, such as newsletters, videos, and even daily puzzles. If you haven’t checked out LinkedIn in a while, it’s worth revisiting it. You’ll undoubtedly find notable updates from colleagues and will see some using it very creatively to highlight their law firms’ successes…”





Because…

https://mashable.com/article/free-ai-courses-march-2025

38 of the best AI courses you can take online for free

It's possible that AI is going to eventually take over the world, but we should have a few years before we get to the point of no return. So how should we approach those years? We may as well learn how to make the most out of AI before it deems that we're all obsolete.

A wide range of online courses on AI can be found on Udemy. And better yet, some of the best examples can be taken for free. We've checked out everything on offer and lined up a selection of standout courses to get you started.



Wednesday, March 12, 2025

Perspective.

https://apnews.com/article/ai-school-chromebook-surveillance-gaggle-investigation-takeaways-381fa82978f27eb85f20d03236820711

Takeaways from our investigation on AI-powered school surveillance

Thousands of American schools are turning to AI-powered surveillance technology for 24/7 monitoring of student accounts and school-issued devices like laptops and tablets.

The goal is to keep children safe, especially amid a mental health crisis and the threat of school shootings. Machine-learning algorithms detect potential indicators of problems like bullying, self-harm or suicide and then alert school officials.

But these tools raise serious questions about privacy and security. In fact, when The Seattle Times and The Associated Press partnered to investigate school surveillance, reporters inadvertently received access to almost 3,500 sensitive, unredacted student documents through a records request. The documents were stored without a password or firewall, and anyone with the link could read them.

Here are key takeaways from the investigation.





Tools & Techniques. (Free trial on desktop version.)

https://www.bespacific.com/diffchecker/

DiffChecker

“I recently discovered a pretty amazing website called DiffChecker. It compares files and visually highlights any differences. You can use it to compare texts you paste right into the browser window, or you can upload documents to compare. It accepts Word docs, pdfs, spreadsheets and image files. To find the differences between two versions of a website, first you’ll have to convert them into txt files. Find an old capture in the Wayback Machine, right click to view page source, then save as a txt file. Then do the same for the live version of the site. A website’s html/css code may not include data files of course – those may be pulled from a background database you can’t access. I’m not saying it will work for every website, but it’s worth a try. The developers at DiffChecker are very responsive too, they quickly answer questions.” Via Marie Concannon Head, Government Information & Data Archives University of Missouri.

https://www.diffchecker.com/



Tuesday, March 11, 2025

Tools & Techniques.

https://www.zdnet.com/article/duckduckgos-ai-beats-perplexity-in-one-big-way-and-its-free-to-use/

DuckDuckGo's AI beats Perplexity in one big way - and it's free to use

I've been a fan of DuckDuckGo for a long time. I find the search engine to be far more trustworthy than Google and I do enjoy my privacy. But when I heard that the company was dipping its webbed feet into the AI waters, my initial reaction was a roll of the eyes.

Then I gave Duck.ai a go -- and was immediately impressed. (DuckDuck Go's AI features launched in June 2024 and came out of beta last week.)

Duck.ai does something that other similar products don't -- it gives you a choice. You can choose between the proprietary GPT-4o mini, o3-mini, and Claude 3 services or go open-source with Llama 3.3  and Mistral Small 3. Duck.ai is also private: All of your queries are anonymized by DuckDuckGo, so you can be sure no third-party will ever have access to your AI chats.



Monday, March 10, 2025

Government security, yes. Individual security, no so much.

https://www.theregister.com/2025/03/09/asia_tech_news_roundup/

India wants backdoors into clouds, email, SaaS, for tax inspectors

India’s government has proposed giving its tax authorities sweeping powers to access private email systems and applications.

The proposal emerged last month in the search and seizure provisions of a tax bill [PDF] which at section 247 requires citizens to provide tax authorities with access to their physical and digital records.

The section also gives tax authorities the power to “gain access by overriding the access code to any said computer system, or virtual digital space, where the access code thereof is not available.” That text appears in the same paragraph describing powers to break down doors or crack safes.



Sunday, March 09, 2025

Interesting take…

https://journals.irapa.org/index.php/JESTT/article/view/1013

Artificial Intelligence in Autonomous Weapon Systems: Legal Accountability and Ethical Challenges

Autonomous Weapon Systems (AWS) are reshaping modern warfare, offering enhanced operational efficiency but raising significant legal, ethical, and regulatory concerns. Their capacity to engage targets without human intervention creates an accountability gap, challenging the application of International Humanitarian Law (IHL). The current legal frameworks are incompetent to define meaningful human control. That complicate the attribution of responsibility when AWS violate human rights. Ethical challenges, including the dehumanization of warfare, algorithmic biases, and indiscriminate targeting, jeopardize civilian protection. Moreover, the proliferation of AWS amplifies global security risks, particularly with their potential misuse by non-state actors. This paper critically examines these challenges, evaluating current legal frameworks, ethical considerations, and regulatory inconsistencies. It proposes war torts, corporate accountability, transparency measures, and binding international treaties to address governance gaps. Supports international cooperation and oversight mechanisms is essential to ensure AWS comply with IHL and human rights law. This research contributes to the global discourse on autonomous warfare, offering practical policy recommendations for ethical and legal governance.





Automating the law of AI?

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5166908

Legal Challenges in Protecting Personal Information in Big Data Environments

The rapid expansion of artificial intelligence (AI) and high-speed big data processing has raised significant legal challenges in safeguarding personal information. Traditional data protection frameworks struggle to address issues such as mass data collection, cross-border data transfers, and evolving cyber threats, particularly in AI-powered, high-speed data environments. This research examines key legal concerns, including compliance with privacy regulations, ethical considerations in AI-enhanced data processing, and enforcement limitations in large-scale data ecosystems. The study employs the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) methodology to systematically evaluate legal frameworks, case studies, and technological solutions for data protection. By applying PRISMA, the research ensures a structured approach to selecting, screening, and analyzing studies on data privacy regulations and their effectiveness. Additionally, AI-driven big data analytics present new challenges in balancing regulatory compliance with real-time, high-speed data processing demands. The study investigates how well-established legal frameworks—such as the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)—address AI-enhanced risks of data breaches, unauthorized access, and personal information misuse. A structured data collection process was implemented using established databases such as Google Scholar, IEEE Xplore, PubMed, Westlaw, and LexisNexis. Quantitative analysis techniques, including descriptive statistics, chi-square tests, regression analysis, and meta-analysis, were applied to examine compliance rates, reported data breaches, monetary penalties, and response times to data incidents. The statistical analysis reveals significant inconsistencies in data privacy enforcement, as compliance rates vary widely (mean: 72.5%, SD: 12.3), and financial penalties under GDPR and CCPA range significantly (median: $1.1M, max: $5.2M). Furthermore, chi-square tests indicate a significant relationship between fines and compliance rates (p < 0.05), highlighting the impact of regulatory penalties on corporate adherence to data protection laws. As AI-powered high-speed data systems continue to evolve, there is an increasing need for adaptive legal frameworks that can address privacy risks while enabling technological innovation. This study emphasizes the necessity of AI-driven compliance mechanisms, automated regulatory monitoring, and real-time enforcement strategies to safeguard personal information in the era of high-speed big data processing.





Thinking real thoughts about artificial people.

https://www.mlive.com/news/saginaw-bay-city/2025/03/do-androids-dream-of-electric-sheep-this-michigan-educators-classes-ponder-the-humanity-of-ai.html

Do androids dream of electric sheep? This Michigan educator’s classes ponder the humanity of A.I.

Matthew Katz knows you might be worried about “The Terminator.”

The Central Michigan University philosophy professor, though, also wants you to consider whether an android — a Terminator or something with less sinister intent — could one day “worry” about you.